High-Def DVD Players Break Below $200 Price Point
Mon Oct 29, 2007 12:09PM EDT
See Comments (9)
The high-definition DVD war continues in earnest. In fact, the ante has just been raised again, as Toshiba has now slashed the price on its HD-A2 HD DVD player from $299 to $198. (Circuit City has the new pricing already; Wal-Mart is expected to cut prices this coming weekend.)
HD DVD enthusiasts have previously been able to get HD DVD for under $200 only through the Xbox HD DVD player add-on drive or from no-name companies with names like Venturer. The Toshiba HD-A2 isn't the highest-end device you can buy (it doesn't have 1080p output, for example), but it's been generally well received by reviewers.
The question now is whether this will turn the tide in HD DVD's favor. Though Transformers was huge for HD DVD, it still hasn't turned momentum in its favor. Despite the HD DVD exclusive, Blu-ray still carried a 51% market share over HD DVD in the week of 10/21, and a 65% lead over HD DVD for the year to date. Since inception, Blu-ray still commands 61% of all discs sold vs. HD DVD's 39%.
But pricing is definitely in HD DVD's favor and getting better. Circuit City's cheapest Blu-ray player, by comparison, is $450, over twice the price of the bargain HD DVD player. (You can find cheaper deals elsewhere, but not much, and nowhere near $198.)
The market, of course, will ultimately be the judge. You make the call: Has HD DVD now entered into your holiday shopping equation?
LINK: The sub-$200 HD DVD player arrives: multiple retailers slashing prices
Comments on High-Def DVD Players Break Below $200 Price Point
Post a Comment
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
-
2 Posted by jirojas on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:35PM EDT Report Abuse
Not yet. I have a bluray in the PS3. Even though I want Transformers in HD. I'll wait until their players are sub $100.
-
3 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse
I bought a DVD recorder that has HD tuning circuits in it for under $100 - they should be able to get a HD DVD player in for that price.
-
4 Posted by godsinventor on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:10PM EDT Report Abuse
Blu-Ray has already won the war. HD-DVD is just giving its dying statements. Despite the fact that Blu-Ray players are more expensive, they have more storage capacity and a higher quality. Plus, the new player cannot output 1080p. The few people who would want a HD-DVD player would at least want to have a HDTV (i.e. 1080i or 1080p). Sorry Toshiba, the war is over. Your guerilla tactics are gonna kill your profits (HD-DVD player but no HD-DVDs, hmmm. a problem
-
5 Posted by ob1john99 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:43PM EDT Report Abuse
What on earth are you talking about? The HD-A2 is 1080i, but the HD-A20, and HD-A3 (the new one)- selling at Sears on Black Friday for $169!!! are all 1080p. The few people who would want a HD-DVD player would at least want to have a HDTV????????????? what does that even mean, of course someone who buys an HD DVD player would want an HDTV...you are a misinformed person.
-
6 Posted by andrew61377 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:53PM EDT Report Abuse
ob1john99, it's you who are misinformed. the a3 is not 1080p. You get what you pay for. http://www.amazon.com/Toshiba-HD-A3-720p-1080i-Player/dp/B000U62N1S
-
7 Posted by neowyndz on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:35PM EDT Report Abuse
"But pricing is definitely in HD DVD's favor and getting better. Circuit City's cheapest Blu-ray player, by comparison, is $450, over twice the price of the bargain HD DVD player. (You can find cheaper deals elsewhere, but not much, and nowhere near $198.)" Hmmm Problem with this statement PS3 is at $399 price point. That is not bad for full 1080p output via HDMI for blu-ray movies as well as select games. Blu-Ray is the superior format, has full Hollywood support except paramount because they sold out to an exclusivity contract (look for Transformers on blu-ray coming 2008) and is more accessible to consumers with the fact I can buy a Sony blu-ray burner and blank blu-ray discs right now in any best buy across the country. HD DVD is dead Gates just doesn't like to admit defeat easily.
-
8 Posted by scottwilkins on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:10PM EDT Report Abuse
Blu-Ray is a lie. Search for "Blu-Ray's dirty little secret" on Yahoo or Google. Interesting reading... HD-DVD is technically and design wise far superior to Blu-Ray. Even though current media formats give Blu-Ray a slight advantage, all other aspects of the formats give HD-DVD the crown for victory. (HD-DVD HD movie space is 8.5 hour, Blu-Ray is 9. So much for bigger, eh?) * HD-DVD can play HD content on regular DVD discs, can't do that with Blu-Ray * HD-DVD is internet enabled by requirement, Blu-Ray is not. (8.5 hours not enough? No problem, get more via the internet...) * HD-DVD is cheaper to buy, own and maintain, Blu-Ray's disc design garuantees you'll be re-buying your movies in a few years when the discs self-destruct! * HD-DVD is future proof, gauranteeing backwards compatibility to all players. Blu-Ray is already changing their format and making older players obsolete. Don't buy into the Sony lie.
-
9 Posted by kristerky on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:53PM EDT Report Abuse
As we now all know, godsinventor was correct. It was only a matter of time. The fire sale that began on black friday should have been a hint. The porn industry once again made the decision on format.(remember Beta vs VHS) Now is the time to get the cheap on the HD-DVD players while you can get the hardware and software. I have both formats now, and I don't see a difference between them quality wise. Yes the Toshiba has the internet capabilities, but from what I have seen offered in content on the discs, I probably won't use that feature anyway.(weak) Wait and buy the next generation of Blu-ray players as they will have the bells and whistles.
1 Posted by klacour on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:52PM EDT Report Abuse
I saw the HD-A2 on the shelves at Wal-Mart for $198 yesterday (Sunday, Oct. 28; Wal-Mart, Brick, NJ). Did someone jump the gun? I don't know, is it a "soft" release? But here is the problem with the Wal-Mart set-up: 1) I went to Wal-Mart to look for the 32" Vizio LCD (at a great price of $597). I literally stumbled upon the A2 - stacked at the bottom of central kiosk HD-TV display. NONE on display. No signs above, and the price was on a sticker on the bottom edge of the shelf. 2) None being on display also meant that NONE were hooked to an HD-TV to show it off. 3) I now had to check for the trifecta - I looked for an HD-DVD movie. Any HD-DVD movie. I couldn't find one - not a single HD-DVD. Now, granted, I only looked for a few minutes, but in that time I was able to find a dozen or more Blu-Ray discs on end-cap displays. Wal-Mart can try to sell all the HD-DVD players they want for any price they want. But for Toshiba to hang their hat on the typically tech challanged Wal-Mart shopper to be able to find the players AND the discs in a technically challanged Wal-Mart store, I am afraid that Sony will then win the next gen DVD format war. And, also add the fact that most non-techically challanged TV buyers (like me and manuy of my friends), in Wal-Mart or Best Buy or Circuit City, are not interested in high def DVDs, given that most of the equipment we have invested in over the past year or two is not capable of playing these discs at 1080p. I'll get a nice, Sony or Samsung up-convert HDMI DVD Recorder for about $150 and be happy until the war is over. Then maybe I'll upgrade my 50" 1080i HDTV to a 1080p.