Tue Jan 15, 2008 12:00PM EST
See Comments (7)
That's a lot of acronyms for one headline, I know, but bear with me. In a move that has the potential for both good and bad, the trade group responsible for the popular USB format has announced that it will roll out this year a version of USB that can carry compressed high-definition video. HDMI is currently the cable of choice for HD technology (though video is carried uncompresed on HDMI cables).
Adding another cabling option, particularly one that is already widely accepted, to the HD arsenal is in many ways a good thing. Computers already come with loads of USB ports, and while HDMI is finding its way to PCs too, it's hardly a universal standard on computers. A high-speed USB port on a TV could make it easy to hook up any computer to any high-def television.
The bad news is in the fine print: The new USB technology would support HD's DRM scheme. In fact, it won't carry video at all unless it is specifically protected by DRM encryption, a move designed to prevent pirated content from being played. That's a bad sign for a number of reasons. First, we need more hardware-driven DRM like we need another collective hole in the head. DRM in software is bad enough; hardware products that won't work unless they detect a DRM scheme could be far, far worse. Second, USB is a mature format that has a long history of not being encumbered by encryption schemes like this. Yet it's not a big stretch to see a DRM-enabled USB connection suddenly becoming required for other formats by vendors paranoid about piracy. Could your printer or even your keyboard someday require a proprietary USB connection, a special cable, and a new computer to support all of this? It's certainly within the realm of possibility.
Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
Well I guess if I had this, I wouldn't be able to play anything on my hard drive. :(
Just don't buy it.
Bad bad bad - nobody will buy it - so yet another dead port on the TV - stupid move - all sorts of things transmit via unencoded USB already, support all that instead. Should be a law making DRM illegal.
In all likelihood it's MFS idea. Your PC won't work unless it's DRM'd to your USB Keyboard, monitor, mouse, finger reader, etc
leftrok, I am not a Microsoft fan, I don't hate them either. However, this doesn't seem like their type of play. This has the fingerprints and MO of the MPAA all over it. The have been trying to control hardware for years and seem to finally be winning. Oh well, perhaps in a few decades people will realize how much they have lost by allowing a bunch of media egotist dictate what data can be transfered and how.
well said. I read something elsewhere about western digital adding a DRM scheme to their hardware drives, too.. Keep DRM away from USB, and get rid of DRM for good.
1 Posted by mgilbert@pacbell.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:17PM EDT Report Abuse
I agree - very bad idea! So, does DisplayPort fit into any of this?