Blu-Ray Buying Guide, Part I

Thu Feb 21, 2008 1:36PM EST

See Comments (26)

The format war is over, Blu-ray won, and you're ready to make tracks for nearest electronics store. Well, hold your horses, fella. Here's a few facts to consider before you crack open your wallet.

Blu-ray players are still way pricey: While Blu-ray managed beat out HD DVD to become the HD disc format of choice, the overall Blu-ray market is still relatively young, and that means high prices—as in $250 or more (as I wrote earlier this week). So, when will prices start falling for Blu-ray players? Hard to say; as Chris wrote, price tags may begin to fall as more manufacturers start coming out with Blu-ray players, but it could be months before Blu-ray prices fall below $200. In short...if you buy Blu-ray now, get ready to pay a premium.

Some players are already out of date: Not all Blu-ray players are created equal. Older Blu-ray decks (which, of course, happen to be the most affordable) may not be able to play the latest interactive bonus features on the new Blu-ray discs. As it stands, there are three Blu-ray "profiles" in the mix:
  • Profile 1.0: The oldest and most basic Blu-ray profile, which lacks picture-in-picture commentary and Internet-enabled features.
  • Profile 1.1: Also known as "Bonus View," this profile adds picture-in-picture video commentaries (a feature available in the first HD DVD players, by the way) but doesn't require support for Internet-enabled bonus features. All Blu-ray players made after November 1, 2007 must be Profile 1.1-compliant (although plenty of Profile 1.0 decks are still on store shelves).
  • Profile 2.0: Also known as "BD-Live" and set for release this fall, this upcoming profile mandates support for downloadable Internet features and "widgets."

Unfortunately, existing Profile 1.0 players can't be upgraded to Profile 1.1, and most 1.1 players can't be upgraded to the upcoming 2.0 standard. (The sole exception is the Blu-ray-equipped PlayStation 3, which can be upgraded via a software download.) So if the latest and greatest extras are important to you, consider paying extra for a Profile 1.1 player, or wait until the fall for a Profile 2.0 deck. On the other hand, if you can live without picture-in-picture commentaries and downloadable Net features, a cheaper Profile 1.0 player might actually be a good bet.

Blu-ray players will play (and upscale) standard DVDs: One question I get asked a lot is whether standard DVDs will work in a Blu-ray player. The answer: yes, and then some. A Blu-ray player will take a 480p DVD and (if you're watching over an HDMI connection) "upconvert" the video signal to 1080p. Now, that doesn't mean that your old DVDs will suddenly look like HD; rather, your Blu-ray player will do its best to extrapolate a 1080p image out of the 480p signal. Results will vary, but in general, you can expect a slightly sharper picture.

Slow start-up times: Get ready to wait when you load up your first Blu-ray disc. Some decks take up to a minute to begin playing a disc from cold start (again, the PlayStation 3 is an exception).

Scant selection of movies: Take a good, hard look at the movies and TV shows out on Blu-ray before you snap up a player. I found a total of about 675 Blu-ray titles on Amazon; compare that with tens of thousands of DVD titles. The number of Blu-ray releases is sure to accelerate now that the format war is over, but for now, there's a good chance that your favorite movie isn't on Blu-ray.

OK, got all that? Good. Click here for part two and some Blu-ray buying ideas.

Comments on Blu-Ray Buying Guide, Part I

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by collarncuffsboy on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:28PM EDT Report Abuse

    Ok, I have to ask since I got confused about the battle between the 2 formats: Are DVDs still going to be made not in HD or Blu Ray format? I just bought a new DVD player and I know it isnt HD or Blu Ray.

  • 2 Posted by blueyesoul1l on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:09PM EDT Report Abuse

    Ben Patterson i love all articles...i learn so much reading your stuff,thank you so much...

  • 3 Posted by snowflakehenri on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    I'm coming in late to this controversy. I have been planning to purchase a DVD/VCR player so I can record some old home movies onto DVDs. Should I wait and get Blu-ray? I'm really confused. I guess I just don't understand the technology and why blu-ray is supposed to be better.

  • 4 Posted by bikeboywon on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:07PM EDT Report Abuse

    you know very little about players. we have tryed them all.stick to writing

  • 5 Posted by leebittome on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:48PM EDT Report Abuse

    WOW, i still prefer the playstaion 3.. i won on iphonevoodoo.com

  • 6 Posted by anicnub on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:55PM EDT Report Abuse

    My personal opinions are (1) BR-DVD player is way too expensive. In this recession environment, not that many people will buy it. (2) Most people will think regular DVD is good enough, no need to upgrade. Just like Windows XP, good enough; no need to buy Vista. (3) BR-DVD only shows its performance in 1080p. Without it, it is waste of money . Very very few people has 1080p TV. Most HDTV is 1080i.

  • 7 Posted by blueyesoul1l on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:09PM EDT Report Abuse

    im with you leebittome ...going to buy a ps3...that seems the best way to go plus my 12 year old son needs a upgrade...

  • 8 Posted by mariovaor on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:07PM EDT Report Abuse

    Before you buy one, how do you know which profile is a blu-ray player? Does it say it in the box?

  • 9 Posted by milk99x on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:20PM EDT Report Abuse

    Facts #6 I disagree with most of your statements. 1080i & 1080p is not that big of difference to most peoples eyes, even up close. 1080i and 1080p are BOTH substantially better than a regular DVD player (480p) and everyone would agree with the 3 side by side. The players are expensive but they are nice if you like movies. Recording to blu-ray is not at a reasonable cost level, but the technology will get cheaper and the capacity of a blu-ray disc is 6-9 times more space than a standard DVD, so when it gets cheaper the blu-ray burners will be great. One contradiction I have with the author is in the updating your blu-ray player to profile 1.1-1.2 etc. The author stated that only the Playstation 3 could do software updates and this is Incorrect. I have downloaded updates twice for my BDP-S300 Blu-Ray disc player in the last 8 months. How? On Sony's website they offer a download of the image of an update disc that can be burned to a Standard DVD and then inserted into the player for an automatic update that takes about 5 minutes. They even offer to send you one in the mail if you don't have a $30 standard dvd burner.

  • 10 Posted by milk99x on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:20PM EDT Report Abuse

    One more note: Before you buy the PS3, consider the fact that if you plan to use it just for movies, you CANNOT program your universal remote or any other remote to control the PS3 blu-ray player. If you have a wife she is going to hate it lol, just ask mine.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 3 Next Last

Post a Comment