Return of the disposable DVD

Fri Apr 18, 2008 12:12PM EDT

See Comments (18)

First we had DIVX, then Flexplay (pictured), and now meet "Einmal," the latest of the watch-it-then-toss-it disc formats. It's a bad idea that just keeps getting...well, recycled.

The Register reports that a company called DVD-D Germany Ltd has just unveiled its "Einmal" (that's German for "once") DVDs, which come sealed in vacuum-sealed cases. Once you crack the seal, oxygen reacts with the disc's "self-destruct" chemical coating, leaving you about 48 hours to watch your movie before the DVD turns into a coaster.

The "Einmal" discs will sell for about four euros, according to the Register; that's more than $6 here, although I'm sure the price would fall to about four bucks if the discs ever made it Stateside (let's hope not).

This isn't the first time that the disposable DVD idea has reared its ugly head. A company called Flexplay has been making disposable DVDs (which have, more or less, the same "self destruct" feature as the new Einmal discs) for a few years now.

Flexplay claims the discs (which cost anywhere from $5-$7; new releases include "Transformers," "Arctic Tale," and "The Golden Compass") are fully recyclable, although environmentalists (obviously) aren't too thrilled with the idea.

And then there was DIVX, a format developed by Circuit City and a group of lawyers in the late 1990s that initially competed with DVD. Instead of self-destructing, DIVX discs (not to be confused with DivX, the video codec) had to be played in a specially-made DIVX player connected to a phone line; once your disc expired (usually after 48 hours), you could either throw it away or pay a fee and get the disc reactivated. DIVX died back in 2001, and I can't say I miss it.

Clearly, I'm not too hot on disposable DVDs—they're expensive, they're bad for the environment (imagine how many of the discs end up in the trash rather than the recycle bin), and c'mon...how hard is it to return a rental DVD? Not to mention the fact that the boom in online video is rendering the whole issue moot.

So, what do you think—would you pay $4 or so for a DVD you could watch and then throw away?

Related:
This DVD will self-destruct in 48 hours [The Register]

Comments on Return of the disposable DVD

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by collarncuffsboy on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:28PM EDT Report Abuse

    If I could burn a copy of it before it expires then yes maybe.

  • 2 Posted by matt_archbold2002 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:11PM EDT Report Abuse

    There is absolutly no need for this with all the online video, and video by mail, and even those dvd vending machines at mcdonalds. Why would anybody want one of these? I see no logical reason or senario that would warrant the need or use of a disposable dvd. Just rent them from netflix like the rest of us. What a waste.

  • 3 Posted by sciencetroll@verizon.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:08PM EDT Report Abuse

    online video is the way to go. disposable dvds would just confuse people because they would open them and forget to watch them in 2 days and be mad because the movie didnt work.

  • 5 Posted by collarncuffsboy on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:28PM EDT Report Abuse

    I love the RedBox DVD Rentals at Mc Donalds. They are also in most of the supermarkets here in Las Vegas. They are great, only $1 plus tax a day, plus I get a free rental every monday. Score.

  • 6 Posted by maori_yelir on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:05PM EDT Report Abuse

    The problem is digital distribution is still in it's infancy. It's hard to make a profit on the internet when anyone can then turn around and download BitTorrent and pirate all the movies they want for free. For the moment rentals are still relavent and cheaper DVDs are making things like Netflix viable but disposable DVDs will still find a market because of how hard it is to turn a profit with the more convenient and envirmentally friendly Digtal Distro.

  • 7 Posted by rogueist on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    Believe it or not, that price is CHEAP in Germany - they will eat it up in seconds. I always find it amazing about the price differences for rented and rental media between the US and European countries - it is like night and day the difference is so stark.

  • 9 Posted by pg021400 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:08PM EDT Report Abuse

    this is actually a cool idea considering it costs plenty o gas at 330 a gallon to go and pick up the dvd and then return it not to mention the fact that most places dvd rentals are 3 or 4 bucks anyways.

  • 10 Posted by uzunoff on Thu Sep 3, 2009 10:30PM EDT Report Abuse

    What If the DVD package cracks during shipping and the DVD "expire" before you get it, or you just make a copy of the DVD before you throw it away. This whole idea would not serve its purpose. And then why would you wait to receive a DVD in a few days, when you can "rent" the movie online and have it in a few minutes. THan how much will that service cost? With 4$ per DVD, I am gessing at least 40$ per month, not counting $$ for the movie. Interesting idea, but not practical.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment