DTV test begins: Antennas, converter boxes cause headaches

Wed Sep 10, 2008 11:20AM EDT

See Comments (10)

The early DTV transition test in Wilmington, N.C. went ahead as planned Monday. But while the FCC's community outreach worked just fine—most viewers were well aware of the analog shutoff—many residents discovered that their old antennas weren't up to the task, or that they weren't using their DTV boxes properly.

Reports vary on exactly how many Wilmington residents called in to complain when their old analog TV sets went dark Monday afternoon. According to Media Life, the "big four" TV stations in town reported a total of 226 calls, while the FCC said that "several hundred" calls came in by late Tuesday.

What's interesting is that the vast majority of those who called in knew in advance that the DTV changeover was happening. For example, of the 226 who called the "big four" stations, only one caller had been caught by surprise, Media Life reports.

Meanwhile, a student survey of local TV viewers found that "only a few" of the 172 residents contacted didn't know that the analog shutoff was happening, the AP noted.

But while it appears that the FCC's outreach program in Wilmington was a success (as it should have been, given that a dozen FCC staffers had been fanning across the area for months), at least one crucial fact slipped through the cracks, according to the AP: That some ancient, puny, or misaligned over-the-air antennas might not be capable of receiving DTV signals. (If you get your TV over cable or satellite, don't worry—you're covered.)

Theoretically, of course, any old antenna (even a pair of rabbit ears) should be able to grab a digital TV signal—but if your antenna isn't aligned properly or you live near hills, trees, or tall buildings, you might be out of luck.

And while analog TVs will work even with a poor signal—you'll just see interference like static and ghosting—digital TV receivers won't give you a picture at all if the signal is too weak.

Another problem, according to the AP: Residents who had DTV converter boxes didn't know they had to tune into, say, channel 6.1 instead of channel 6.

Learning how to tune a DTV box is easy, but dealing with an old antenna can be a little trickier—indeed, you might need to get on the roof and realign the thing, raise it higher, or buy a new, more powerful model.

Not sure how your over-the-air antenna will fare once the "big switch" arrives on February 17, 2009? Check out AntennaWeb.org; its FAQ has plenty of tips on how to get the best reception. It also has a searchable database of antennas for sale, along with local DTV stations and antenna locations; just plug in your address to get the right channel numbers and compass headings.

So, show of hands: Who's still using an over-the-air antenna? Rooftop or rabbit ears? Got it aligned properly?

Related:
Old antennas cause complaints in digital TV test [AP]
A few more things you should know about the DTV transition [Yahoo! Tech]

Comments on DTV test begins: Antennas, converter boxes cause headaches

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by fcaraco on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:59PM EDT Report Abuse

    If you use cable directly into a cable ready tv without a box will the transition still affect you?

  • 2 Posted by lesterjbrent on Thu Sep 3, 2009 6:49PM EDT Report Abuse

    No. If you have cable with or without a cable box you will not be affected. The cable company processes all the signals before it sends it to you. The transition is only for people who use antennas to get local broadcast television.

  • 3 Posted by brice_78 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:13PM EDT Report Abuse

    Kill your TV, read a book, go for a hike!

  • 4 Posted by nighteye23 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:38PM EDT Report Abuse

    Is the antenna issue really what they make it out to be? They make these really expensive "DTV" antennas and push people into buying them and tell them that rabbit ears won't work. I think it's a bunch of crap. When I got my HDTV with a built-in tuner, I just hooked up a small, cut-off peice of coax cable to it (about 6 inches long) to test it and I was able to get every digital channel tuned in. That certainly is lesser quality than rabbit ears. I then tried rabbit ears and it worked just as well. When nothing was hooked up, that's when I couldn't get any sigals. I think just about ANY antenna would work with these DTV boxes and don't be fooled by these expensive ones they are pushing at you. Test your old antennas before wasting your money!

  • 5 Posted by nighteye23 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:38PM EDT Report Abuse

    I did forget to mention that I do live within 10 miles of all the broadcasting stations. If you live far out, you could potentially have problems with just using a 6-inch piece of coax as an antenna :)

  • 6 Posted by phil.seymour on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:09PM EDT Report Abuse

    Out here in Redding CA I have been watching digital broadcast TV since the superbowl. It's great. I love the dolby 5.1 sound. I run it through my home stereo system. I use an old set of rabbit ears to receive HD stereo TV. This the best thing since color TV.

  • 7 Posted by mikeaffronte on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:19PM EDT Report Abuse

    Well the american public get (*******) again, when will goverment stop ordering private business to do things "for the good of the public", this HDTV is becoming a nightmare, let analog die its own natural death after broadcasters find that there is only about 2 to 3% of anaolog recivers on thier field of broadcast, because gradually the anaolog tv will die thier own natural death and there will be only HDTV units to buy.

  • 9 Posted by rye_rum on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:57PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have this problem with my antenna. Antennaweb says I can get 1 station, and I do get 1 station (in digital). I get about 9 analog stations. I live 40+ miles from a broadcast tower from Louisville. Antenna's will make or break your reception if you are any distance from the towers at all. This isn't about watching American Idol as some have suggested. This is about receiving detailed information about potential severe weather threats in the area, jail excapes, boil water advisories, etc. At 40+ miles, rabbit ears just can't do it. (But I do get very good reception with rabbit ears on VHF on analog.)

  • 10 Posted by pilot076@sbcglobal.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:12PM EDT Report Abuse

    Wondering why we are not getting the signal thru the converter box for channel 12 here in Redding, Ca since they have brodcast that they have switched over to HD? We are getting channel 24, 9 thru the converter box. If anyone out there knows what to do to get channel 12 signal thru the converter box please reply. It would be much appreciated.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment