Reader mail: Will I need a cable box after the DTV transition?

Wed Dec 3, 2008 5:25PM EST

See Comments (15)

Tom writes: Thanks for your post about the DTV deadline and whether or not I'll need a new TV. Here's my question, though: I get my signals though cable, but I don't have a set-top box. Will I be OK after the analog shutoff?

Dear Tom: I'm glad you asked. As a cable viewer without a cable box (or a digital TV, I'm assuming), you're in a special situation—and unfortunately, you might need a set-top box after all.

First, a little background. While the FCC is mandating that all broadcast TV stations shut off their analog signals by February 17, 2009, there's no such requirement for cable operators. But here's the thing: Most of the big cable carriers want to go all-digital—digital signals use much less bandwidth than analog—and they'll be able to do so once local TV stations switch off their analog broadcasts.

But as this Ars Technica article explains, the FCC ruled in 2007 that cable operators must continue to provide local TV stations (but not basic cable networks like TNT or TBS) to its analog TV customers until at least 2012. That's the good news.

The bad news? Cable operators are free to choose how to deliver those analog signals—either by converting the digital signals from your local TV stations to analog (which the all-digital carriers won't want to do), or by providing converter boxes—and if your carrier decides to give you a digital-to-analog converter box, they can charge you for it (probably $5-to-$10 a month). From the FCC's DTV FAQ:

If the cable company provides the customer with a set-top box, any costs related to it will be determined by the cable company. Therefore, it is recommended that analog cable customers contact their cable company to ask if a set-top box will be needed, when it will be needed, and if there will be a cost.

So Tom ... yes, you might need a converter box; call your service provider and ask what their plans are. Also, keep in mind that the digital-to-analog converter boxes for cable aren't the same as the over-the-air converter boxes, and the government is not providing subsidies for cable converter boxes. Yeah, I know—but that's the deal, unfortunately.

Comments on Reader mail: Will I need a cable box after the DTV transition?

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by jseyfield on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:43PM EDT Report Abuse

    I asked Comcast and they assure me my analog cable will continue to work but they were vague on how long and whether I'll need some converter in the long-run. I'm not a person that rails on the government every chance they get but they have really outdone themselves this time. The public still doesn't know what the heck is going on and this coupon system of theirs is a joke. I have no problem with the digital transition but the way it's been carried out has been a fiasco. I can only imagine what the outrage will be like on Feb 17.

  • 2 Posted by d_gunde on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:50PM EDT Report Abuse

    If people still don't know what's going on they aren't paying attention. It takes very little effort to just call someone for an answer. Websites and phone numbers that answer questions are placing ads everywhere.

  • 3 Posted by magpagbst on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:03PM EDT Report Abuse

    i agree . . . people who are STILL having issues with the pending conversion to digital tv don't deserve to own a tv . . . a majority of these people will only be missing out on court tv and jerry springer . . .

  • 4 Posted by headphonedude on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:17PM EDT Report Abuse

    Better Safe than sorry, right? i got the cb a couple months ago just to be safe.

  • 5 Posted by diggeryo on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:43PM EDT Report Abuse

    Amen, Patsarge. I agree with you 100%. The problem isn't that people don't understand what they're being told or don't know where to go for information. The problem is that people are being given conflicting information. I can go to numerous websites set up for this and be given different answers as to whether I need a box or not. I even called Comcast numerous times to find out what was going on, and some of their reps told me I needed a box while others said I didn't. You can't blame consumers for not understanding what's going on when the people giving them the information don't underatand themsevles.

  • 6 Posted by lvman167 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:01PM EDT Report Abuse

    So magpagbst could you explain to me please?

  • 7 Posted by jr.mpls on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:42PM EDT Report Abuse

    i live in an apt with lousy reception and no out door antenna. i've tried 2 different indoor antennas with 2 different converters - the issue that i am have is a weak signal - any ideas on how to inpmrove signal strenth with indoor antenna so that conveter box will work?

  • 8 Posted by cluhu57 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    techno-impaired here & it IS confusing! We've heard the 'blanket reply' . . cable will cover . . " WE R among the not so few who can't afford a New TV, new/different provider, cb's 4 the rooms that only get "God's TV" right now! Ha-aaa-rummmphhhh!

  • 9 Posted by evansmark37 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:56PM EDT Report Abuse

    I have Cable One as my carrier in Lakeside AZ and I was told by them that even though they were going to get the signal in digital they were going to broadcast it to us in analog.I have a nice 52 inch HD digital tv and I am tired of trying to watch football games in analog the picture is lousy.I have a digital HD cable box and the picture is still lousy on analog channels,all I want is all my channels in digital.I live in an apartment complex and they won't let us have satellite and the only way you can watch tv here is to have satellite or cable.I just want all my channels in digital so I can watch all my channels with a decent picture.I just think i'ts unfair that the cable company is going to get the picture in digital and broadcast it to us in analog. Posted by ME

  • 10 Posted by magpagbst on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:03PM EDT Report Abuse

    lvman . . . sure . . . if your tv is analog only, it's probably time to get a new one (but that's another issue) . . . anyway, if one is getting straight cable (and the cable company gives conflicting info) . . . all you can do is wait and see what happens after the conversion to digital . . . if your tv doesn't get a signal, you will either need a conversion box to continue with cable or an over the air converter box . . . you are very welcome! . . .

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 Next Last

Post a Comment