DTV transition: To delay or not to delay

Tue Jan 13, 2009 11:42AM EST

See Comments (300)

Obama's transition team and Democratic lawmakers want to push back the analog TV shutoff date by as much as 90 days, while the FCC warns that such a move would only make matters worse. My view: It's time to rip off the Band-Aid.

First of all, here's the latest: Pointing to recent reports that federal funding for DTV converter box coupons has run out (well, for now, at least), Obama's camp is calling for a delay in the February 17 DTV transition date, while Senate Democrat Jay Rockefeller is reportedly prepping legislation that would push the date back 90 days.

Current FCC Chairman Kevin Martin counters that delaying the analog TV shutoff date would only add to viewer confusion, and he proposes a couple of alternatives: Either a new infusion of funding from Congress for the coupon program, or eliminating the 90-day expiration date for coupons that have yet to be redeemed.

So, what to do? After all, the Feb. 17 deadline is barely a month away.

Personally, I say we stick with the deadline. But why, if so many people are still unprepared? Based on evidence from the various DTV tests conducted in the past several months, it's not lack of awareness that's the problem—rather, it's viewers who are "either procrastinating," "in denial" (as one observer put it), or suffering from "technical naiveté" (from this spot-on L.A. Times editorial).

As far as "technical naiveté" goes, that's perfectly understandable—and that's why there are phone banks ready to answer questions, and as the L.A. Times notes, the FCC recently doled out $8 million in grant money for volunteer community outreach.

But while I've yet to run into anyone who's totally ignorant of the coming transition, I've met plenty of viewers who fall into the "in denial" category—and for them, nothing short of seeing their old TVs go dark will snap them into reality.

One more factoid: According to this New York Times story, about 6.8 percent of U.S. households aren't ready for the DTV transition—meaning that 93.2 percent are ready. (Remember, only those with older analog TVs and over-the-air antennas will be affected; if you've got a TV with a digital tuner, or you're getting your signals over cable or satellite, you're all set.)

That said, Congress needs to step up and approve more money for the converter-box coupon program, enough so that the million-plus names on their waiting list can get their coupons in a timely (key word: timely) manner—as in days, not weeks.

No, the DTV transition won't be fun—or easy. But as many others have pointed out, it'll be a painful process no matter when we do it, and the sooner we get started (and we've been working on this thing for 10 years now), the sooner we can use the newly available spectrum for next-generation wireless networks—4G, to be specific—that'll benefit all of us.

So, what do you think: To delay, or not to delay?

Related:
What you need to know about the DTV transition [Yahoo! Tech]

Comments on DTV transition: To delay or not to delay

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by dcsoccer25 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:39PM EDT Report Abuse

    I say we do it. Like you said, it's got to be done eventually and if we delay it now someone will just find another reason to delay it later. People have been warned, Let's just do it.

  • 2 Posted by jkleong@sbcglobal.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:36PM EDT Report Abuse

    What do you do with people who had gotten the coupons but had missed the 90-day deadline because they had lost the coupons? Is it possible for the FCC or Congress to revise the rules to allow applications for a set of new coupons a second time? Under the current rules, they are not allowed. These people do not know friends or relatives who do not need a converter box for their TV sets and who can request the coupons on their behalf.

  • 3 Posted by rorbincalendar on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    Obama's call for this delay is the first confirmation of what 50 percent of the population has known all along. BARRACK OBAMA IS AN EMPTY SUIT! _________ Let this ridiculous notion serve as notice to the rest of you of what to expect over the next 4 years. Jimmy Carter move over.

  • 4 Posted by chardomylardo on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:21PM EDT Report Abuse

    Viewers have had years to get ready for this transition. I say that we do it now. No matter when we do it, people will have problems with it.

  • 5 Posted by maclingman on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:02PM EDT Report Abuse

    Please don't delay it anymore, I'm sooo sick of those commercials

  • 6 Posted by zbearx on Thu Sep 3, 2009 11:00PM EDT Report Abuse

    I like Obama, but he's wrong on this one. It's time to do this...the country has been talking about it and preparing for it for 5 years. As I see it, delaying won't help people procrastinating or in denial...they won't do anything until they go dark. Those technologically challenged (some number fewer than 7% of the country's TV viewers) need the motivation of having to solve the problem to get at finding the help they need. The coupon program being out of funds is no reason to stop. That problem can be solved by Congress, and in the meantime people can buy their own boxes and get reimbursed. I say DO IT.

  • 7 Posted by peter_simone2003 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:08PM EDT Report Abuse

    just get it done and be rid of this nonsense. those that can't afford boxes should be given free tv for life. Obama will fix everything

  • 8 Posted by hostileapostile630 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:20PM EDT Report Abuse

    rorbincalendar....YES! It would be rediculous to push this back after so much planning. Just do it, I'm not sure exactly how much more money I'd be ok with them approving for this thing, but I guess you can't just leave some people hanging. On the other hand...how many people still legitimately need coupons and how many are just failing to act? Most of the population is ready and the best way to convince the rest to get ready is just to do it.

  • 9 Posted by montemail on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    rorbincalender..sorry but we've heard your crap for the last 8 years!!Obama may not be right in this case, by the way he hasn't been sworn in yet, but relax!!We had to deal with your crap for 8 years so get an issue!! Just SHUT UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 10 Posted by ckanotz on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:26PM EDT Report Abuse

    How do you use this computer thing? Can't somebody just give me back my darn TYPEWRITER!!!

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next Last

Post a Comment