Bad Idea: Non-Skippable Ads on DVDs

Mon Nov 26, 2007 3:47PM EST

See Comments (29)

Is that hurtling car gonna crush Bruce Willis? Find out—right after these messages.

Yes, most standard DVD movies already come loaded with an annoying number of previews and coming attractions (which, thankfully, you can usually skip). But try this on for size: the bloggers at Zatz Not Funny unearthed a patent application from IBM that would allow for non-skippable ads at any point on a DVD. Wonderful.

According to the patent filing, a DVD could come embedded with a certificate that determines whether the disc should be played with advertisements; if the DVD is flagged for ads, then the non-skippable commercials could run at any point during the video. The ads could also be grabbed from the Internet (provided the player in question has a Net connection) or simply come pre-loaded onto the disc.

Now, before we all freak out, keep in mind that IBM's patent was filed over a year ago, and that there's a good chance the idea will never work its way onto our DVDs. Also, writer Davis Freeberg suggests some relatively benign possibilities for the patent: for example, maybe the ads would only be activated on budget versions of a disc (say, a $3.99 copy of the new "Die Hard" flick, as opposed to the standard $29.95 version) or even free DVDs.

I guess that's fine, as long as the no-commercial discs are still available. But here's what worries me: the possibility of downloading fresh ads from the Internet, an idea that might entice advertisers who've been loathe to buy commercial time on DVDs in the past. (Most standard DVD players can't connect to the Net, but Ethernet-equipped HD DVD players and upcoming Blu-ray decks certainly could.) In that case, I could easily envision discs with pre-roll ads—similar to those in movie theaters—through which you'd be forced to sit. Would disc prices drop if pre-movie ads became part of the package? Sadly, I doubt it; after all, the last time I checked, movie ticket prices continue to climb despite all the pre-roll commercials.

Related:
IBM Files For DVD Advertisement Patent [Zatz Not Funny!]

Comments on Bad Idea: Non-Skippable Ads on DVDs

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 1 Posted by somebodys_here on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:32PM EDT Report Abuse

    Balls. I could see skippable ads for new movies (The same ads that play in theatres would be a nice feature) before the movie but never ones that you couldn't skip through. If this ever makes it into HD/Blu-Ray discs, I can easily say that I would not allow the player a net connection. Why would I let it have one anyway? USB firmware updates- that's better than a direct connection to internet for the tech savvy guys, right? Oh well, we'll probably never see this in action anyway, so I doubt we should start getting worried.

  • 2 Posted by lastguyin2005 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:56PM EDT Report Abuse

    Personally, I enjoy the trailers that play before a theatrical release. Assuming they are interesting, its a good way to see what the newest movies are. And without them, we wouldn't have those great trailers that everyone talks about (Cloverfield).

  • 3 Posted by kola10002000 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:53PM EDT Report Abuse

    Who ever places an add on a product that I have paid for will be less likely to receive my business.

  • 4 Posted by rorbincalendar on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:51PM EDT Report Abuse

    They already place a ton of commercials on many of my sons childrens DVD's and this is why as soon as I buy it I rip a copy with NOTHING on it but the video that I bought. Then I put the original in a box. ____________I am breaking NO laws. It is my video, I am not sharing it with anyone and we will watch it exactly how we want to watch it. Nothing more, nothing less.

  • 5 Posted by posshogg19 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:16PM EDT Report Abuse

    Indeed. I am not paying for something with ads on it. If it has ads it should be free. (CABLE AHEM) Just my $0.02

  • 6 Posted by campy454 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:17PM EDT Report Abuse

    Personally, I'm offended by the fact that I have to watch "commercials" before seeing a movie I paid for - either in the theater or on DVD. Enough is enough!

  • 7 Posted by ramj925 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    This does sound outragious. I would personally not but these movies if they do start caring commercials during the movie. I do however like watching the previews before the movies in the theatres, it is nice to know what new movies are coming out plus it gives people time to get snacks and get seated before the movie starts. As far as the DVD discs go, I do like having the option of watching the upcoming movie trailers (Like having a link under the Special Features menu.) But I will not but DVD's, Blue-Ray Discs, HD-DVD's that have ads that I have to watch during my movie.

  • 8 Posted by tamrhill on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:55PM EDT Report Abuse

    Very Bad Idea. I agree with robincalendar. I Buy DVDs for the Movies not the commercials. It seems you can never get away from them!

  • 9 Posted by r-n-c@att.net on Thu Sep 3, 2009 8:25PM EDT Report Abuse

    I don't mind trailers, but commercials that you can't skip trough in the middle of my movie... no way. Even if that would lower the prices of discs.

  • 10 Posted by dmcdizzle19 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    Who enjoys ads at movies? Previews yes, commercials no. The theater was the last place on Earth we had to escape commercials. Not only are we forced to watch these commercials, they are three times as long as regular TV spots. They know we are a captive audience with no remote to change the channel. Whats next? Tivos (DVRs) that force us to watch certain ads?! not in my house!

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 3 Next Last

Post a Comment