HDTV Prices Are INSANE!!

Tue Nov 21, 2006 1:04PM EST

See Comments (180)

If you spent any time on the East Coast during the '80s you'll remember an electronics store called Crazy Eddie's. Radio and TV ads had the owner, Crazy Eddie, screaming about the store's savings. When talking about flat-screen TV prices this holiday season, I feel a little like Crazy Eddie. "These prices are INSANE!!"

Just a few years ago, 50-inch HDTV plasma TVs retailed for upward of $7,000. Early in 2006, we saw the first sub-$2,000 50-inch HDTV model from a company called Vizio. The company has since dropped its price to $1,699, but that's not the MOST INSANE deal offered. Costco is offering a 50-inch HDTV plasma monitor from a company called Maxent. With an automatic Costco discount, this set retails for $1,499. It's the first sub-$1,500 50-inch HDTV model on the market. "THAT'S INSANE!!"

As a savvy consumer you're asking yourself a few questions right now, foremost of which is, "Vizio? Maxent? Who are these guys?" These are new companies that have gone after a very niche market: the budget consumer. Unlike Panasonic, Sony, and Phillips, Vizio and Maxent aren't manufacturing TVs for the entire range of HDTV consumers. They have limited distribution through big-box discount stores, and their business model makes sense: don't try to please every consumer or try to be in every retail outlet. They've picked their market and are keeping costs down by pursuing the budget buyer exclusively.

Next question: "Are these HDTV plasmas any good?" For the price, these TVs are very good, but compared to high-end plasma sets, you can definitely see a quality difference. Several PC magazines have written about these sets (Vizio and Maxent), and they received surprisingly good reviews. It's good to see what you'll miss out on if you opt for a lower-cost set, but those features and differences probably won't matter if cost is your number one consideration. (And for most of us, isn't it always number one?) As for my personal opinion, I did a segment for Good Morning America showing sets from across the price spectrum. As I scanned the studio to inspect the sets, I noticed that the Vizio I included was a little less crisp, the colors a little less vibrant, and the video inputs a little less plentiful or diverse than the higher-priced plasmas'.

One thing you might consider with a budget set is purchasing an extended warranty. I generally don't advise extended warranties, but if it makes you feel more comfortable and doesn't cost as much to get the warranty as it would to buy a brand name, trust your gut. Buying a budget HDTV means you have to do your homework, but remember that THESE PRICES ARE INSANE!!

Check out more insanely priced TVs in Yahoo! Tech's Television Resource Center.  

Comments on HDTV Prices Are INSANE!!

Post a Comment

Join in the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.

  • 2 Posted by cliftonprewitt on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:27PM EDT Report Abuse

    Bought a 50" LG PC3D (720i) for $2000 at Brandsmart in Atlanta. I thank them for taking my money. Could not get service at the "Major" stores! Last year I bought a 57" Toshiba (1080i) Rear projection... Toshiba knows nothing about service or warranty. The speakers have vibrated the convergence so bad it is unwatchable. I gave it to my 84 yr old dad. When will the chains HELP me spend money instead of runaround?

  • 3 Posted by brians1960 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:13PM EDT Report Abuse

    what a joke--they tease with "bargain hdtv's" and all we get is fluff about the most expensive and least reliable(plasmas)

  • 4 Posted by gilly_bean_baby on Thu Sep 3, 2009 4:09PM EDT Report Abuse

    Bargain? Where? I'm sorry, but the "average" "budget seeking" family can NOT afford $1500 for a TV. We splurged a few years ago, and got a 36" TV with our taxes, and paid $300. That was nuts to me, because $300 is a LOT of money to working families who live frugally, and don't have much extra left over. I'm sure in the author's mind, on his budget, that it's insane to NOT buy a TV that costs 2 months house payments, but he should really think before using the word bargain when referring to a box with a screen that costs that much. Maybe compared to 3 years ago it is a good deal. But bargain it is not. Give it to me for $500, and I'd be more than happy to upgrade to HDTV. As it is, this family's bargain hunter is not impressed.

  • 5 Posted by onestop912 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:45PM EDT Report Abuse

    Just bought a 42" Samsung from bestbuy for $1,500

  • 6 Posted by splitbmx248 on Tue Nov 28, 2006 1:28PM EST Report Abuse

    You neglect to state the facts that neither Maxent nor Vizio have any form of a tuner in them, rendering them completely useless unless you go with HD service from your cable provider. Post #4 if $300 dollars is a lot of money, you shouldn't be reading this article. Also, there are more expenses that go in to buying a HDTV than just the TV alone (cables, HD service and so on) so the idea of you would buy one at $500 barely seems possible to me. If you want a good HDTV go to a Best Buy or Circuit City and try listening to what the sales person has to say. You might be pleasantly surprised at all the choices available. They dont work on commission so they arent forcing you in to anything, if you dont want what they ofeer say so.

  • 7 Posted by oscarfiggy_1 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 7:46PM EDT Report Abuse

    i just bought a 50 inch plasma high def t.v for around $2500 at sears it gotta admit its expensive but its the best, colors are great and with the HD cable it makes the xbox look GREAT!!!!! and it comes with 24 month no pay

  • 8 Posted by arrow61095 on Thu Sep 3, 2009 2:58PM EDT Report Abuse

    I recomend talking to friends who may have HD sets and to do research online. Wikipedia can be a great resource to find out exactly what different features do. When I went to start looking for my first HDTV, I had only read about 3 online articles and knew more than the workers in Best Buy (The guy I talked to didn't even know what a Digital comb filter was or the difference between 720p and 1080i). While it is possible to get someone who knows about HD at a local retailer(Best Buy/Circuit City/etc...), ask yourself if they could afford the piece of technology on a retail income, and how much experience do they have (most stores hire a lot of temporary workers because of the holiday rush). One other important thing to keep in mind when buying an HDTV is how many High Definition inputs do you need (For DVD, PS3, Cable, Satellite, etc...), and what types of inputs (HDMI,DVI, and/or component). Also, do you need a tuner or do you have a cable/satellite box that will take care of this for you (sets without tuners tend to be lower priced, and you may be able to save some money)? A good thing to do is to make a list of the minimum amount of features that you want. If you dont know what something is -look it up on an online encyclopedia or ask someone in a forum.

  • 9 Posted by bjackstudios on Thu Sep 3, 2009 3:08PM EDT Report Abuse

    Don't forget - source is just as important as the television you purchase. An HDTV without HD programming is not an HDTV at all - in fact it looks terrible and often worse than old school tube TV's. If you're looking to save some money, a Maxent TV will do a great job paired with a decent high definition service and a nice Samsung upconvert DVD player (standard DVD's are only 480p, they too will not look wonderful on an HDTV). And just for the record I always recommend extended service plans on plasmas, they're not nearly as durable as LCD's and can break down easily.

  • 10 Posted by sha_an on Thu Sep 3, 2009 9:18PM EDT Report Abuse

    I got the Panasonic 42 inch plasma for $1000. I thought that was really good as what I am comparing other prices.

More Posts: First Prev 1 2 3 4 5 Next Last

Post a Comment